Thanks everyone for using Draw3Cards! August was a very good month for us: Yearly stats and Monthly Stats
3

Can you cast a card while it's being discarded? For example, take Mind Rot

If I have an instant, let's say Path to Exile, Mind Rot is played, and I choose to discard Path to Exile and another card. Can I play Path "while I'm discarding it" and really lose only one card?

[[mind rot]] [[path to exile]]

flag
Please try not to embed card images directly in paragraphs - it jumbles the flow of the text and makes your question harder to read. You can put them at the end of the question (if it's a short one), like this, and it's still easy to read. – ripper234 Nov 19 at 6:19

4 Answers

5

No. Keep in mind that you may only cast spells when you have priority. If Mind Rot is cast targeting you, you can cast an instant in response while Mind Rot is still on the stack, but you will still have to discard 2 cards (or your entire hand if you don't have that many) when it does finally resolve. No player receives priority while a spell is resolving, so you cannot cast a spell that you are discarding (unless another effect would explicitly allow you to, like the Madness ability).

[[Grave Scrabbler]]

link|flag
4

Madness is a replacement ability, meaning that it replaces the event of discarding the card with playing it. that's why you don't have to discard anothr card: it is discarded, but the discard is transformed

link|flag
2

You can only play something like Path to Exile before the discarding happens. You can not cast a spell or use an activated ability during the resolution(When you would do the actions printed on the card) of a spell or ability that would you discard. Cards with Madness is the of the few exceptions to this rule along with cards that abilities that can trigger when the card is discarded, but even those abilities don't get to be used until the spell is resolved.

link|flag
0

That depends actually. If you have only two cards in hand, you can play [[[path to exile]]] before [[[mind rot]]] resolves and discard only one.

608.3. If an effect attempts to do something impossible, it does only as much as possible. Example: If a player is holding only one card, an effect that reads “Discard two cards” causes him or her to discard only that card. If an effect moves cards out of the library (as opposed to drawing), it moves as many as possible.

link|flag
True, but I don't think that was the spirit of the question. – CodeSavvyGeek Apr 23 at 3:49
Seems relevant to me. Not every player understands that casting a spell is not the same as a spell resolving. – Shushoto Apr 23 at 13:19

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.