Featured post: The 2nd Great Designer Search!
Registration starts Sep 29.
6

1

I think that a simple website for playing magic would be ideal. No heavy desktop client, and just simple cards with rules set by the players.

Has this been done before ?

flag

5 Answers

5

I don't know about a website, but there are two methods of playing Magic online with a desktop client (it's not particularly heavy though):

Magic Online

Developed by Wizards of the Coast, this is the "official" way to play Magic online. It's a quality game, where the software knows all the Magic rules and doesn't let you cheat. You must use priority, phases, etc... in order to play it correctly.

The downside - In order to draft in Magic Online, you have to pay money for each "virtual booster", and you can only ever play with the virtual cards you own.

Magic Worktation / Netdraft

These are free alternatives to Magic Online. Workstation is a program for managing a collection and playing Magic games. It does't know the rules of Magic, but it does have a concept of "hand", "library" "graveyard" and so forth. You can manually draw cards, tap lands for mana, play creatures, and play a full game of Magic using Workstation.

Netdraft is a separate client that allows you to play drafts. It handles connecting several players, seating arrangements, and lets each player draft a deck. After he's finished, a game the follows in Magic Workstation (though usually you play only a single opponent and not a swiss-style tournament).

While Magic Online contains everything you need to play, in Workstation/Netdraft you have to find your opponents on IRC channels such as #draft4you and #magic-league (see MagicLeague for more information).

Draft Simulators

There are a few:

These don't require any software.

link|flag
This was the closest that I could find to an answer here. I guess that all of these programs require a specific application which makes it out of luck for Mac or Linux players. – ungamedplayer Nov 7 at 8:50
there are a few projects in java around, but they are possibly not advanced enough. for example, MTGForge works great, but has no multiplayer. i'm also doing a game, but it isn't nearly playable – Silly Freak Nov 22 at 11:19
As for draft simulators, I like the one at draft.bestiaire.org -- it shows the cards well (better than the Wizards simulator), it has Zendikar, the bots draft pretty well, and it shows you what everybody drafted at the end along with individual player scores. You can then export to MWS/Apprentice to test your deck. As far as I understand, it even learns "what's good" by noticing what people draft in different situations and adjusting accordingly. – Avish Nov 22 at 12:00
2

MWS (Magic Workstation) is a very good alternative to playing Magic, in my opinion. I recently sold all my cards to a close friend, and now I play only tournaments by sending him the decks I want to play with. Magic Workstation lets me test those decks, and create new ideas.

The downside of the program is that it doesnt have the magic feel as much as Magic Online does: not all the cards have a picture, even when you download image files, and cards don't have the 'new' look like the series after 8E have in the real game.

Beside that, it's a great tool for developing, testing, and simulating Sealed / Draft deckbuilding.

link|flag
3

There is a site that allowes you to draft with your friends or vs. bots. it is: ccgdecks.com

you can download the decks to Magic Worksation and play out the draft matches later.

link|flag
There is also a draft simulator in TCGPlayer - magic.tcgplayer.com/db/article.asp?id=7366 – ripper234 Nov 22 at 11:51
3

According to MrOrange's Youtube page: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hXVrSMkOT4g, The official MTGO app will be web based shortly and work on multiple platforms. In the video he states that everything he is showing in running in Safari on a Macbook Pro.

link|flag
1

There also is a program called Forge. Here is the introduction from the site Forge. It is free and multiplatform.

My computer program Forge lets you play the card game Magic: The Gathering against a computer opponent using all of the rules. This is very different than playing solitare Magic with Apprentice or Magic Workstation because the AI will attack and play spells. Currently there are over 1,800 cards ranging from old power cards like Ancestral Recall and Lightning Bolt to newer cards like planeswalkers. The user interface is basic, but it does let you download all of the cards pictures and view them while playing the game.

(If you don't know Magic, the easiest way to learn is to download this demo fromhere or here for Windows, it is 85 MB. Also checkout the YouTube videos at playmagic.com.)

You can also play sealed deck, draft, or the new quest mode. In draft mode the AI drafts for the 7 other opponents and builds the decks from the cards that it chooses. In the quest mode you start out with a few cards and the more games that you play the more that you win. As you get more cards you can update and change your deck.

There is also a "quest mode" where you start out with a small, random cardpool and you win more cards by playing against opponents. This is a scaled down version of Shandalar that is only menu based. On easy mode your goal is to win 10 matches. Easy mode is well easy because you always win cards after the match whether you win or lose. On some of the harder modes you only win cards if you win. Quest mode is challenging since the computer uses cards that are better than the stinky ones that you have. The computer opponents are divided into three categories so they get progressively harder.

Forge supports a number of keywords such as exalted, fear, flying, shadow, flanking, protection, wither, flash, defender, reach, and haste. Forge now also has a mana pool and supports creature enchantments.

The AI is very simple and does the best that it can. It tries to do reasonable actions. Sometimes the computer seems smart and sometimes it doesn't. Truthfully the AI plays random cards from its hand and each card has some AI code programmed into it. The computer can play cards like Counterspell but in all other cases the computer will never respond to a spell or ability on the stack. Also the computer will only play spells during its Main phase.

Forge runs on Windows, Linux, and Macs. You can download Forge from the panel on the right.

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.